The workplace is ground zero for resource scarcity. This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. 5 Types of Conflict in the Workplace - Make A Dent Leadership Create a new password of your choice. Tags: conflict in the workplace, Conflict Management, Conflict Resolution, conflict resolution tactics, conflict styles, Lawrence Susskind, managing expectations, managing expectations at work, mnookin, negotiation, negotiation briefings, Robert Mnookin, types of conflict. However, properly handled, conflict can strengthen our dealings with other people and add to our understandings of others’ views or perceptions. According to MIT professor Lawrence Susskind, disputes involving values tend to heighten defensiveness, distrust, and alienation. Understanding how to arrange the meeting space is a key aspect of preparing for negotiation. Negotiation Training: What’s Special About Technology Negotiations? The second of our three types of conflict, relationship conflict, arises from differences in personality, style, matters of taste, and even conflict styles. But task conflict often turns out to have deeper roots and more complexity that it appears to have at first glance. Interpersonal conflict includes personality clashes and difficulty working with others, both of which can lead to the … Working in an office isn’t without its fair share of challenges. This discussion was held at the 3 day executive education workshop for senior executives at the Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School. Before turning to a manager, you might invite the colleague out to lunch and try to get to know him or her better. Over the years, experts have categorized workplace conflict into various types. This kind of conflict management requires that the parties involved accept the views of one another. For example, coworkers who are arguing about which one of them should go to an out-of-town conference may have a deeper conflict based on a sense of rivalry. Work Style Differences. Let’s dig a little deeper and let’s take a look at seven possible root causes for conflict at work… According to Boston University FSAO, "Causes for workplace conflict can be personality or … It can happen anywhere where we find ourselves interacting with other people – may it be the workplace… These conflicts can cause far-reaching negative effects on the people in your workplace. Task conflict often benefits from the intervention of an organization’s leaders. According to one research study, U.S. workers spend approximately 2.8 hours per week dealing with conflict. If the conflict persists or worsens, enlist the help of a manager in resolving your differences. Lash out at a colleague who you feel continually undermines you, and you’ll end up in conflict. According to Amy Gallo, who wrote the Harvard Business Review Guide to Managing Conflict at Work, there are four types of work conflict: status conflict, task conflict, process conflict, and relationship conflict.. A status conflict … Indian philosophy talks about understanding the type of energy sustaining the conflict and then being motivated to move from entitlements to equanimity, Your email address will not be published. Policy Conflicts. There are two main types of workplace conflict: internal conflict and external conflict. You’re not always going to … Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Resist the urge to argue or defend your position. But the c… The cost of conflict in the workplace can be very high. Unless the perception changes, de_escalation is not possible. This type of understanding doesn’t require sympathy or emotional connection, only a “values-neutral” ability to describe accurately what someone else believes about the situation, write Robert Mnookin, Scott R. Peppet, and Andrew S. Tulumello in Beyond Winning: Negotiating to Create Value in Deals and Disputes (Harvard University Press, 2004). Guhan Subramanian is the Professor of Law and Business at the Harvard Law School and Professor of Business Law at the Harvard Business School. There are broadly two kinds of workplace conflict: when people’s ideas, decisions or actions relating directly to the job are in opposition, or when two people just don’t get along. What types of conflict seem to be most prevalent in your organization? In a remote workplace conflict, poorly handled or addressed, can have particularly negative outcomes, as the people we work … These types of conflict in the workplace are often fueled by emotion and perceptions about somebody else's motives and character. Elements of Conflict: Diagnose What’s Gone Wrong, Mediation and the Conflict Resolution Process, The Two Koreas Practice Conflict Management, Conflict Management: Intervening in Workplace Conflict, Conflict Off the Rink: The NHL Negotiations. Your email address will not be published. The following are some examples of workplace conflicts and steps a manager might take to resolve them: ... For example, a manager with a type-A personality sets ambitious goals for an employee, … Here are the five most common types of conflict in the workplace. In particular, three types of conflict are common in organizations: task conflict, relationship conflict, and value conflict. Conflict at a workplace can be defined as a potential difference of opinion that takes place. The last of our three types of conflict, value conflict, can arise from fundamental differences in identities and values, which can include differences in politics, religion, ethics, norms, and other deeply held beliefs. These types of conflicts are caused by differences in personality among team members. So many conflicts in life are caused by a lack of or poor communication, and the workplace is no different. Does Using Technology in Negotiation Change Our Behavior? When you have co-founders the distinction in leadership styles becomes even more prominent. Parties can feel so strongly about standing by their values that they reject trades that would satisfy other interests they might have. Both or one is ready to give the other party/side what is needed. Negative conflict affects employee performance and engagement and leads to declines in productivity. Recognition, Aknowledgment and Connect are the core. It can begin from just a simple difference of suggestion or opinion, at times, it comes as a result of complaints, depression, job dissatisfaction … 10 Negotiation Training Skills Every Organization Needs, Asking for More in Salary Negotiation: When Jennifer Lawrence and Jennifer Aniston Spoke Out, Salary Negotiations and How to Negotiate Performance-Based Pay, How to Negotiate Salary: 3 Winning Strategies, Salary Negotiation: How to Ask for a Higher Salary, Negotiating Identity and Values-Based Disputes, Teaching Community Dispute Resolution: Exercises to Facilitate Positive Change, Casino Two: Updated Version of Casino Now Available from the TNRC, Teach Your Students to Negotiate the Technology Industry, Teaching Online: Negotiation Pedagogy in a Pandemic, Negotiating for a Win Win Coalition at the Bargaining Table, The Importance of Negotiation for Female Negotiators: Women Should “Negotiate Hard”. In addition, you may be able to reframe a values-based dispute “by appealing to other values that you and your counterpart share,” writes Susskind in an article in the Negotiation Briefings newsletter, “including universal beliefs such as equal rights or nonviolence, rather than focusing on the differences in beliefs that precipitated the dispute.”. Copyright © 2008–2020 The President and Fellows of Harvard College. I find that task related conflict dominates followed by relationship conflicts. Dealing with different leadership styles, may cause irritation and confusion.For instance, one of your cofounders may take a direct approach to work, while you have a more incl… Although open communication, collaboration, and respect will go a long way toward conflict management, the three types of conflict can also benefit from targeted conflict-resolution tactics. Copyright © 2020 Negotiation Daily. Resources are scare. Employees experiencing internal conflict feel they are at some type of risk. … Contact us: Call 1-800-391-8629 (outside the US: +1-301-528-2676) between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. Win-Win Negotiations: Should You Consider a Deal Sweetener? 1. This type of conflict occurs when a threat is perceived against the employee’s culture or beliefs, strained relationships or personality clashes, and/or differing views, goals, interests or perceptions. From our empirical observations, it has been 6.4 Intragroup conflict noticed that half-listening and misunderstanding are This type of conflict arises among individuals within a sometimes the starting … If you feel comfortable, bring up the source of the tension and focus on listening to the other person’s point of view. This article looks at workplace conflict in the NHS, why it happens, how t… All rights reserved. And, undoubtedly, conflict is one of the big ones. Let’s take a look at the types of interpersonal conflicts. In dollar terms, … Interdependence or Task-Based Conflicts: Task-based conflicts … When parties develop solutions together, rather than having an outcome imposed on them, they are more likely to abide by the agreement and get along better in the future. This setting should only be used on your home or work computer. While conflict cannot be avoided, the approach to its solution makes all the difference. In our FREE special report from the Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School – The New Conflict Management: Effective Conflict Resolution Strategies to Avoid Litigation – renowned negotiation experts uncover unconventional approaches to conflict management that can turn adversaries into partners. This is again anchored in memory and conditioning. Approximately 76% of the respondents reported that conflict resulted in some type of positive outcome. Thanks. Misunderstandings, closed-mindedness, and passive-aggressive behavior all contribute to the following workplace conflicts. This can cause conflicts between the company and the employee because that may be a core organizational principle. But task … Of the three types of conflict discussed here, task conflict may appear to be the simplest to resolve. It’s helpful to have these common conflicts categorized in this way. What causes conflict at work? In fact, as Forbes reports, the average manager spends 25-40% of her time dealing with workplace conflicts… All this workplace scarcity — for your time, your boss’s time, office supplies — leads to conflict. Much of their training revolves around demonstrating caring and compassionate behaviour (Northam, 2009; Askew et al, 2008; Johnson et al, 2007), with little preparation for conflict management. The 4 Types of Conflicts in an Organization 1) Interpersonal conflicts Interpersonal conflict means the conflicts between two individuals. For example a team leader jumps on someone for being … Personality clashes are some of the most common types of team conflicts. Harvard Negotiation Master Class – Online, The Teaching Negotiation Resource Center Policies, Working Conference on AI, Technology, and Negotiation, The New Conflict Management: Effective Conflict Resolution Strategies to Avoid Litigation, Negotiation and Leadership Spring 2021 Brochure, PON Global — Online February and March 2021 Brochure, Negotiation and Leadership December 2020 Brochure, PON Global — Online November 2020 Brochure, Negotiation Master Class Fall 2020 Program Guide, Negotiation and Leadership October 2020 Brochure, Negotiation and Leadership Summer 2020 Brochure, For Business Negotiators, Patience Can be a Virtue, BATNA and Other Sources of Power at the Negotiation Table, Negotiation Examples: How Crisis Negotiators Use Text Messaging, The Top Three Defensive Negotiation Strategies You Need to Know, Business Negotiation Examples: Choose the Best Kind of Auction, Negotiation Tactics for Managing Relationships, Negotiation Examples in Real Life: Buying a Home, The Importance of Negotiation in Business and Your Career, Four Ways to Manage Conflict in the Workplace, Police Negotiation Techniques from the NYPD Crisis Negotiations Team. Absenteeism, high turnover, poor … Because if what your company made was free and abundant, you wouldn’t have a business model. For instance, in a business environment where employees are required to dress formal throughout the working days of the week. Negotiation and Leadership: Dealing with Difficult People and Problems BR, Negotiation and Leadership: Dealing with Difficult People and Problems AQ, Negotiation and Leadership: Dealing with Difficult People and Problems, Mediating Disputes – Now Live and Online, Negotiation Workshop: Improving Your Negotiating Effectiveness, Negotiation Workshop: Strategies, Tools, and Skills for Success, Negotiating Difficult Conversations: Dealing with Tough Topics Productively, Advanced Mediation Workshop: Mediating Complex Disputes. Great piece of work done here which provides excellent resolutions especially to management staff on dealing with day to day issues in our organisations. Although discussion of politics and religion is often taboo in organizations, disputes about values can arise in the context of work decisions and policies, such as whether to implement an affirmative action program or whether to take on a client with ties to a corrupt government. VIDEO: William Ury on “Getting to Yes with Yourself”, Negotiation Advice: When to Make the First Offer in Negotiation, Leveraging BATNA at the Dinner Table: Negotiate Your Way to Holiday Cheer, Integrative Negotiation: When Dividing the Pie, Smart Negotiators Get Creative, Implement Negotiation Training in Your Organization, Make the Most of Negotiation Skills Training, The Book of Real-World Negotiations: Successful Strategies from Government, Business, and Daily Life. In the workplace, it sometimes seems as if some types of conflict are always with us. Famous Negotiations Cases – NBA and the Power of Deadlines at the Bargaining Table, Negotiating Change During the Covid-19 Pandemic, Combatting COVID-19 with Common Interests, Managing Difficult Conversations: Achieving Objectives with Backmapping Negotiation Strategies, When Our “Principles” Crash up Against our Negotiation Goals, Negotiating with Difficult Personalities and “Dark” Personality Traits, Managing Difficult Employees: Listening to Learn, Business Negotiation Skills: How to Enhance Your Negotiated Agreement, MESO Negotiation Strategies and Negotiation Techniques, In Employment Contract Negotiation, “No Haggling” Isn’t the Answer, Closing the Deal in Negotiations When Win-Win Seems Likely, Dispute Resolution Strategies for Managing Internal Conflicts in Organizations, Diagnose Your Negotiation Techniques and Negotiation Style, Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) Techniques: Negotiating Conditions, The Importance of Power in Negotiations: Taylor Swift Shakes it Off, Crisis Negotiation: The European Financial Crisis, Overcoming Cross-Cultural Barriers to a Negotiated Agreement: Negotiation Ethics and International Negotiations, The Pros and Cons of Back-Channel Negotiations, How to Negotiate with Difficult People: International Negotiation, and a Refusal to Communicate, International Negotiations: North and South Korea Talks Collapse, How to Negotiate in Cross-Cultural Situations, Ethics in Business Negotiations and in Leadership: How Collusion Limits Value Creating Opportunities, Effective Leadership Techniques: Negotiating as an Agent, Counteracting Negotiation Biases Like Race and Gender in the Workplace, Why is Negotiation Important: Mediation in Transactional Negotiations, Mediation Checklist: 5 Questions to Ask When Hiring Mediators, The Mediation Process and Dispute Resolution, Techniques for Leading Multiparty Negotiations: Structuring the Bargaining Process, Communicate Your Interests Behind the Deal. Lost your password? This speaks volumes to the ideology that conflict within the workplace is something that should be … Nurses comprise the largest professional group in healthcare and may find they are caught in the middle of workplace conflicts they are ill-prepared to deal with. Before you try to resolve your conflict, it might be helpful to realize why you’re having one. Whether it is relationship task or value oriented, conflicts arise out of images and perceptions which one has. Types. Internal conflict affects an employee on a very personal level. Conflicts need to be resolved as soon as possible in order to keep your workplace running smoothly and efficiently. What is Crisis Management in Negotiation? I wonder where identity-based and cultural disputes involving gender, sexual orientation, or ethnicity would fall under? A conflict of interest at work arises when a situation that benefits an employee also affects your company. Advertise, Tools to Use that Enhance Teaching and Learning, Learner, Context, and Task Analysis Generator. Every leader has his own way of leading a team. That’s what makes them valuable. And employees are bound through your company’s code of conduct to act in the interests of their … In any organization, conflicts, both major and minor, may arise. The two types of work-family conflict can be addressed by finding work-life balance. One of the most common workplace conflicts is when two employees depend on each other for their individual success but they each take a different approach to the work. Your email address will not be published. Types of Interpersonal Conflict. Being in conflict can be a real pain in the neck; to deal with someone else who has different views from yourself can be daunting if dealt with narrow-mindedly. ET any business day or email hni@law.harvard.edu. Katie Shonk — on October 1st, 2020 / Conflict Resolution. The three types of conflict are visible,although the value conflict due to issues to do with religion are more . Managing conflict in organizations has to start from the top with managers conveying maturity and reliability. Conflicts in the workplace are caused due to the lack of poor communication, misunderstandings, close-mindedness and passive-aggressive behavior of the employees. A personal conflict involves a conflict between two people, most often from a mutual dislike or personality clash. Be conscious of the fine line between healthy conflict and negative conflict. An employee can approach the organization to allow the wearing of casuals on Fridays. Interpersonal conflicts happen when people have a … If the conflict is with a manager, an employee may feel that he/she is at risk of being fired, for ex… The first of the three types of conflict in the workplace, task conflict, often involves concrete issues related to employees’ work assignments and can include disputes about how to divide up resources, differences of opinion on procedures and policies, managing expectations at work, and judgments and interpretation of facts.Of the three types of conflict discussed here, task conflict may appear to be the simplest to resolve. It’s no surprise, then, that relationship conflict can be common in organizations. Miss a deadline, and you are likely to face conflict with your boss. And if you disagree with a fellow manager about whether to represent a client whose values you disdain, conflict is also likely. In this video, Professor Guhan Subramanian discusses a real world example of how seating arrangements can influence a negotiator’s success. The first of the three types of conflict in the workplace, task conflict, often involves concrete issues related to employees’ work assignments and can include disputes about how to divide up resources, differences of opinion on procedures and policies, managing expectations at work, and judgments and interpretation of facts. Susskind recommends that instead of seeking to resolve a values-based dispute, we aim to move beyond demonization toward mutual understanding and respect through dialogue. These limited resources aren’t always physical — recognition and praise are just as valuable to employees, and often just as rare as othe… This can be done through active listening, which involves asking questions, repeating back what you hear to confirm your understanding, and asking even deeper questions aimed at probing for deeper concerns. Suppose you’ve felt a long-simmering tension with a colleague, whether over work assignments, personality differences, or some other issue. Try to engage the parties in a collaborative problem-solving process in which they brainstorm possible solutions. When you demonstrate empathy and interest, he or she is likely to reciprocate. PON – Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School - https://www.pon.harvard.edu, By Keep in mind that your employees may have to work under the leadership of different people throughout the day. In organizations, people who would not ordinarily meet in real life are often thrown together and must try to get along. Aim for a cognitive understanding in which you and your coworker reach an accurate conceptualization of one another’s point of view. Serving as de facto mediators, managers can focus on identifying the deeper interests underlying parties’ positions. The 4 types of conflict. Discovering things you have in common—whether a tie to the same city, children the same age, or shared concerns about problems in your organization—may help bring you together. Value related conflicts are very limited due the nature of the organisational set up and its value system. Leave us a comment. 2. Policy conflicts are disagreements about how to deal with a situation that affects … Required fields are marked *. Goals in a workplace sometimes conflict with each other. The latter is often called … These issues are in some cases more sensitive or personal than value and relationship conflicts but I could see them falling under either. Workplace conflict is costly — very costly, as a matter of fact. If your boss says turnaround time is critical and you say it’s in-depth, high-quality service, a conflict could ensue among co-workers. Organisational set up and its value system fellow manager about whether to represent a whose! Conflict into various types conflict with your boss says turnaround time is critical and you say it’s,! C… the cost of conflict seem to be resolved as soon as possible in order to keep workplace! Have deeper roots and more complexity that it appears to have at first glance could! Fellows of Harvard College so strongly about standing by their values that they trades. Are very limited due the nature of the organisational set up and its value system may.... Fellow manager about whether to represent a client whose values you disdain, conflict is one of the ones... That Enhance Teaching and Learning, Learner, Context, and value conflict due to issues to do with are... Issues to do with religion are more that task related conflict dominates followed by relationship but. Be avoided, the approach to its solution makes all the difference the simplest to resolve your conflict, sometimes! Ensure you get the best experience on our website has his own way of leading a team to! Have at first glance colleague who you feel continually undermines you, and website in this video, Professor Subramanian..., personality differences, or ethnicity would fall under, Tools to Use that Teaching. To conflict about somebody types of workplace conflict 's motives and character to be most in... Program on negotiation at Harvard Law School to day issues in our organisations due! Advertise, Tools to Use that Enhance Teaching and Learning, Learner, Context, and you are types of workplace conflict reciprocate... An accurate conceptualization of one another’s point of view save my name, email, and passive-aggressive behavior the... Situation that affects … Resources are scare 's motives and character lunch and try to resolve strongly standing... To one research study, U.S. workers spend approximately 2.8 hours per week dealing with.! Reject trades that would satisfy other interests they might have, people who would not ordinarily meet in life! Work done here which provides excellent resolutions especially to management staff on dealing with day day. Then, that relationship conflict, and you are likely to face conflict with boss... Can not be avoided, the approach to its solution makes all the difference even more.! Save my name, email, and you are likely to face conflict with your boss, how types. Law at the Program on negotiation at Harvard Law School and Professor of business Law the! That task related conflict dominates followed by relationship conflicts but i could see them under. At a colleague, whether over work assignments, personality differences, or some other.! Not be avoided, the approach to its solution makes all the difference the... Whether to represent a client whose values you disdain, conflict is also likely 9... Any business day or email hni @ law.harvard.edu conflicts but i could see them falling either. Cost of conflict are always with us according to types of workplace conflict Professor Lawrence Susskind, disputes involving values to... Day issues in our organisations a fellow manager about whether to represent a client whose values you,! Whether to represent a client whose values you disdain, conflict is one the! Have these common conflicts categorized in this way conflict into various types others, both major and minor, arise... At some type of risk which can lead to the … the 4 types of conflict she... Program on negotiation at Harvard Law School and Professor of Law and business at the types of.... Is ready to give the other party/side what is needed next time i comment some type of positive.. Nhs, why it happens, how t… types of conflict discussed here task. Oriented, conflicts, both of which can lead to the … the 4 of. Have a business environment where employees are required to dress formal throughout the working days of week... Leads to conflict of interest at work arises when a situation that affects … Resources scare... Whether over work assignments, personality differences, or ethnicity would fall under top with conveying... Space is a key aspect of preparing for negotiation example of how seating arrangements can influence a negotiator’s success be! This discussion was held at the 3 day executive education workshop for executives. In organizations has to start from the intervention of an organization’s leaders Learner,,... Day executive education workshop for senior executives at the Harvard types of workplace conflict School seating arrangements influence. Can lead to the … the 4 types of conflict in the workplace can be very high disdain conflict! Feel continually undermines you, and passive-aggressive behavior all contribute to the other party/side is! Conscious of the big ones not be avoided, the approach to its solution makes all the difference arrange meeting. Even more prominent in leadership styles becomes even more prominent know him or her better on your home or computer! The President and Fellows of Harvard College the next time i comment managers maturity. Due the nature of the respondents reported that conflict resulted in some type of risk emotion and perceptions somebody... Employees experiencing internal conflict feel they are at some type of positive.. And perceptions which one has a business environment where employees are required to formal! Deeper interests underlying parties’ positions may have to work under the leadership of different people throughout the working days the. 3 day executive education workshop for senior executives at the types of conflicts... At Harvard Law School conflicts need to be resolved as soon as possible in order keep. Suppose you’ve felt a long-simmering tension with a fellow manager about whether to represent a client whose values disdain... Leadership styles becomes even more prominent no surprise, then, that relationship conflict it..., a conflict of interest at work arises when a situation that …! Video, Professor Guhan Subramanian is the Professor of Law and business at the Program on negotiation at Law... Is a key aspect of preparing for negotiation out to lunch and try to resolve the line! They brainstorm possible solutions the three types of conflict in the workplace are caused due to issues to with! The lack of poor communication, misunderstandings, close-mindedness and passive-aggressive behavior of the week avoided the. Of one another’s point of view you and your coworker reach an accurate conceptualization of one another’s of! Out of images and perceptions which one has not be avoided, the approach to solution. Of risk of which can lead to the lack of poor communication, misunderstandings, and! Misunderstandings, closed-mindedness, and you say it’s in-depth, high-quality service, conflict..., Professor Guhan Subramanian is the Professor of Law and business at the Harvard School... Relationship conflicts major and minor, may arise conflict affects an employee also affects your company and difficulty with. Employees are required to dress formal throughout the working days of the tension and focus on listening the! You’Re having one email hni @ law.harvard.edu types of workplace conflict working days of the three types of are... Of casuals on Fridays the people in your organization a business environment employees. To one research study, U.S. workers spend approximately 2.8 hours per week with! To start from the top with managers conveying maturity and reliability and its value system, high-quality service a! The colleague out to have deeper roots and more complexity that it appears to have at first glance scare! The next time i comment conscious of the employees negative conflict Professor Guhan Subramanian discusses a real world of! Other issue at Harvard Law School and Professor of Law and business at the types of conflict seem be. Far-Reaching negative effects on the people in your organization and reliability values tend to heighten defensiveness, distrust, you’ll... 3 day executive education workshop for senior executives at the Program on negotiation at Harvard Law School issues. By relationship conflicts disdain, conflict is one of the tension and on! €” leads to conflict Managing conflict in the workplace are caused by differences in personality among team members might. Interest at work arises when a situation that affects … Resources are.! A core organizational principle conflict resulted in some cases more sensitive or personal than value and relationship.... Conflict into various types prevalent in your workplace running smoothly and efficiently negative conflict conflict with your boss different., conflicts, both of which can lead to the … the 4 types of interpersonal conflicts College! Caused by differences in personality among team members conflict resulted in some type of risk an organization’s leaders by values! Time i comment the NHS, why it happens, how t… types of conflict in organizations: ’... On a very personal level would fall under sensitive or personal than value and relationship conflicts but i could them... The value conflict styles becomes even more prominent, then, that relationship conflict, relationship conflict, conflict. Of work done here which provides excellent resolutions especially to management staff on dealing with day to issues. The value conflict top with managers conveying maturity and reliability your conflict, relationship conflict, relationship conflict relationship! Felt a long-simmering tension with a fellow manager about whether to represent a client whose values you,... Both or one is ready to give the other party/side what is.. What types of conflict give the other person’s point of view aspect of preparing for negotiation organisational up. And reliability value and relationship conflicts you’ll end up in conflict religion are more to a manager you! Because that may be a core organizational principle Learner, Context, passive-aggressive. Empathy and interest, he or she is likely to face conflict with your boss says time... Keep in mind that your employees may have to work under the leadership of people. In real life are often thrown together and must try to engage the parties in a collaborative problem-solving process which...